Heat Transfer

Lumped system assumption

Lecturer: Jakob Hærvig

What is the lumped system assumption and why?

Most heat transfer problems are complex because temperature varies with both space and time

  • In lumped systems, temperature only varies with time (not space)

    \(\quad T=f(x,y,z,t)\) \(\quad \rightarrow \quad\) \(\quad T=f(t)\)

  • Significantly simplifies the analysis!
  • A roast beef (not lumped system)
    A copper ball (lumped system)

    Starting point of lumped system analysis

    Consider a body of arbitrary shape with

    • At time $t=0$ the body is exposed to convective heat transfer from the outside:
      • Surrounding temperature $T_\infty$
      • Heat transfer coefficient $h$
      • Surface area $A_s$

    Derivation of the lumped system equation

    Energy transferred to body during $\text{d}t$:

    \(\dot{Q}=h A_s (T_\infty-T) \text{d}t \) \(= m c_p \text{d}T\) \( =\rho V c_p \text{d}T\)

    Because $T_\infty$ is constant, we may expand $\text{d}T$:

    \(\dot{Q}=h A_s (T_\infty-T) \text{d}t = \rho V c_p \text{d}(T-T_\infty)\)

    ..Re-arranging:

    $$ \frac{\text{d}(T-T_\infty)}{T-T_\infty} = -\frac{h A_s}{\rho V c_p} \text{d}t$$

    Now, intergrate from $t=0$ where $T=T_i$ to $t$ at which $T=T(t)$:

    \( \displaystyle\text{ln}\frac{T(t)-T_\infty}{T_i-T_\infty} = -\frac{h A_s}{\rho V c_p}t\)

    Exponential on both sides gives lumped system equation:

    \( \displaystyle \frac{T(t)-T_\infty}{T_i-T_\infty} = \text{e}^{-\frac{h A_s}{\rho V c_p}t}\)

    The time constant for lumped systems

    Introducing $b=hA_s/(\rho V c_p)$, we obtain:

    \( \displaystyle \frac{T(t)-T_\infty}{T_i-T_\infty} = \text{e}^{-\frac{h A_s}{\rho V c_p}t} = \text{e}^{-bt}\)

    The time constant ($1/b$) describes the rate at which the system approaches the surrounding temperature $T_\infty$

    • Large $b$: Temperature approaches $T_\infty$ quickly
    • Small $b$: Temperature approaches $T_\infty$ slowly

    Validity of lumped system assumption

    We define a Biot number

    $$ \text{Bi}=h L_c/k $$
    • with the characteristic length $L_c=V/A_s$

    If $\text{Bi}=0$: lumped system assumption is exact

    If $\text{Bi}\leq 0.1$: lumped system assumption is resonable accurate

    If $\text{Bi}> 0.1$: lumped system assumption is inaccurate

    Example: Fast temperature measurements with thermocouples

    The temperature of a gas stream is to be measured by a thermocouple. The thermocouple junction can be approximated as a 1 mm diameter sphere. The junction properties are $k=35$ W/m·K, $\rho=8500$ kg/m$^3$ and $c_p=320$ J/kg·K.
    How quickly can the thermocouple respond to changes in temperature when the convective heat transfer coefficient between the junction and the gas is $h=210$ W/m$^2$·K?